25 September 2023

Time Was

Start the conversation

Reviewed by Robert Goodman.

By Ian McDonald, Tor, $21.75.

British author Ian McDonald is best known for his futuristic novels set in India (River of Gods) or South America (Brasyl) or Turkey (Dervish House) or his more recent kick-arse Game of Thrones on the Moon series Luna. In Time Was he shifts a gear. This novella is an intimate time travel tale.

Emmett, an antiquarian bookseller in London, comes across a letter tucked into an old book of poetry. The letter, written in World War II, sends Emmett on a quest to find out more about its author.

His research takes him to a woman named Thorn who lives in an old house in the Fen country where he learns the name of the author of the letter (Tom Shadwell) and its recipient (Ben Seligman). But when he takes a photo of the two people to a contact at the British War Museum and it matches a picture of two young men from the early years of World War I, things start to get weird.

Time Was is a story of time travel, of quantum physics obsession and, ultimately, of love. As Emmett searches for clues about the strangely peripatetic Tom and Ben, McDonald pays homage to some of the great time travel tales, like Doctor Who, but also to other popular science fiction and fantasy tales as diverse as Blade Runner and Highlander,.

But it is also a story about the madness and futility of war, with the narrative jumping from the World Wars to the war in Bosnia, to the rape of Nanking and the Russian Revolution.

Time Was is short, but its brevity is to great effect. And, as a novella, you can read it in a single sitting.

This review first appeared in Aurealis #115, Australian Science Fiction and Fantasy Magazine, www.aurealis.com.au.

This and over 300 more reviews can be found at www.pilebythebed.com.

Start the conversation

Be among the first to get all the Public Sector and Defence news and views that matter.

Subscribe now and receive the latest news, delivered free to your inbox.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.