3 November 2026

Wagga childcare operator loses fight to reopen after disturbing CCTV revelations

| By Oliver Jacques
Start the conversation
playground photo

Angel’s Paradise Wagga has been closed since 2024. Photo: Angel’s Paradise Adaptive Montessori – Wagga/Facebook.

A Wagga childcare provider has lost its bid to overturn a service cancellation after a tribunal exposed a pattern of severe safety failures, including infants eating food scraps off the floor and a toddler breaking his collarbone from a fall.

According to a published decision handed down on Friday (30 October), the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal upheld the cancellation of Angel’s Paradise Wagga’s provider approval, finding the company was not a fit and proper operator of a childcare service.

The centre was initially shut down in September 2024 after concerns included children being left unsupervised and staff failing to properly respond to injuries.

But the tribunal’s latest decision goes further, finding the problems were not isolated mistakes but part of a pattern of repeated failures across the centre.

Among the most serious was the case of a toddler, identified as AB, who suffered a broken clavicle after falling at the centre in August 2024.

The published decision stated the tribunal examined CCTV footage showing the child attempting to climb a small bookshelf before falling heavily onto his head and shoulder. The child was seen lying on the floor in discomfort and later resting his head on a highchair table.

The tribunal criticised the centre’s response to the investigation. Operator John Tanios had initially told the regulator he had reviewed CCTV and found no accidents involving the child that day. Mr Tanios later explained he had watched the footage at triple speed on his mobile phone to save time, leading the tribunal to find his response was unsupportable, although it did not make a finding that he had deliberately lied.

“Mr Tanios sought to diminish the risks on the basis that accidents happen,” the tribunal stated in its judgement.

“Accidents do indeed happen, however the issue is whether they happen because of non-compliance and unacceptable risk, or happen in spite of demonstrated compliance and appropriate risk controls. It is clear from the footage that AB’s fall and injury directly resulted from a lack of supervision and acceptable risk management.”

READ ALSO Man denied full access to police body cam footage in NCAT ruling

The published decision also listed other failures.

Children were left unsecured in highchairs and bouncers, infants climbed on furniture, and food scraps were accessible on the floor. The tribunal also heard of poor hygiene, dangerous chemicals in unlocked cupboards, electrical cords found within reach of children and inadequate supervision.

Evidence tendered to the tribunal indicated staff received little or no induction or ongoing training, while some senior responsibilities were given to inexperienced workers.

The tribunal also found that child protection concerns recorded by staff – including possible indicators of domestic violence and sexual abuse – were not properly investigated or reported.

Mr Tanios, who was based in Sydney and rarely attended the Wagga centre, argued he always tried to do the right thing and believed his staff were generally compliant. However, he said he was operating three services with more than a hundred staff and could not ensure they were compliant every single day. He considered that there had been some bad luck and he had spent thousands of dollars on recruitment.

READ ALSO Court finds tribunal's order to overturn councillor's suspension 'wholly inadequate' to address misconduct

He said he provided evidence of remediation, governance changes and a willingness to accept stringent conditions.

But the tribunal found there was little evidence he had effectively managed or addressed the problems before the centre was suspended.

“Lacking in his submissions and evidence was any sense of genuine accountability or any semblance of remorse for the way the service had previously been operated and the consequences for children in the care of the service,” the tribunal concluded.

It found there remained an unacceptable risk to children if the company were allowed to operate a childcare service.

The decision means the cancellation of Angel’s Paradise’ provider approval stands, ending the company’s attempt to have it overturned.

The centre has not operated since its suspension in September 2024. According to the published decision, it has been locked out of its premises by the landlord since November 2025 over alleged rental arrears of $110,000.

Original Article published by Oliver Jacques on Region Riverina.

Subscribe to PS News

Sign up now for all your free Public Sector and Defence news, delivered direct to your inbox.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Start the conversation

Be among the first to get all the Public Sector and Defence news and views that matter.

Subscribe now and receive the latest news, delivered free to your inbox.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.