26 October 2026

Top cop points to clear link between political debate and threats against MPs

| By Chris Johnson
Start the conversation
AFP Commissioner Krissy Barrett

AFP Commissioner Krissy Barrett says MPs are ultimately responsible for decisions they make about their own personal safety. Photo: AFP.

Australian Federal Police Commissioner Krissy Barrett has delivered a stark warning to parliamentarians that the temperature of political discourse is directly related to the level and nature of threats made against them.

As security measures at Parliament House are being reassessed in the wake of the violent car ramming attack on independent MP Helen Haines in her Wangaratta electorate, the police commissioner said politicians had to make their own decisions about personal safety.

The AFP will continue briefing federal MPs, senators and staff on security measures, but it was up to each parliamentarian to determine what they do with the advice.

Appearing on the ABC’s Insiders program Sunday morning (25 October), Commissioner Barrett said threats against politicians rise when public political debate gets particularly inflammatory.

“It does have a direct correlation to what we see in terms of threats and abuse, and sometimes it’s very immediate,” she said.

The Commissioner said there was no doubt the threat environment had worsened for politicians in recent times.

“When I start work every morning, one of the first things I do is read a report that summarises all of the threats that have been reported to the AFP over the last 24 hours,” she said.

“Now, some days that report is pages and pages long … We do see examples where there are particular announcements or things like you’ve just described [One Nation’s cartoons depicting politicians being hit by cars], there is a reaction amongst the community.

“Words matter, and we do see the flow-on impact from that … My hope is that this really causes people to pause and have a think about what’s happening in this country and the impact of that.

“And if this is not the incident, then what is?”

READ ALSO Police and ASIO brief MPs on personal security measures following Haines attack

The volume of threats has increased dramatically since it became easy to make them online, as opposed to sending physical hate mail letters, and posting inflammatory political commentary and images on social media.

While police did not want to hamper freedom of expression or get involved in political debate themselves, the Commissioner said they had a law enforcement role when threats become violent.

She rejected the notion that such threats were permissible because they were examples of free speech.

“I would challenge any Australian to read some of these threats and some of the abuse that is reported to us from federal parliamentarians and for anyone to argue that that is free speech or political discourse,” Commissioner Barrett said.

She also said protecting parliamentarians was more about how AFP resources were used than it was about the size of the budget it has to work with.

Some MPs have called for the AFP to be given more funds to be directed to protecting them.

Requests have even been made for personal duress alarms to be given to parliamentarians, which the Commissioner said was being considered – although she added that calling 000 remained the best option in an emergency.

“It’s about having the flexibility to evolve our capabilities, invest in technology and respond to changing threats,” Commissioner Barrett said.

“At the end of the day we’re here to give advice, but I would say it’s up to the individual parliamentarian to make those decisions … I think there is a place for duress alarms, but we need parliamentarians to understand what a duress alarm does and doesn’t do.”

READ ALSO Public servants just might have some legitimate concerns about their safety too

On Dr Haines specifically, the Commissioner said the AFP investigators were focused on trying to establish a motive of her alleged attacker, Brendan Nugent, who has been charged over the incident.

That process could take weeks and even months, she said.

“Sometimes it is difficult to determine a clear motive,” the Commissioner said.

“There is media reporting around his mental health, around some of the social media footprint that is out there in terms of different issues that he may or may not be aligned with.

“We need to work through all of that to determine whether it is directly linked to her role as a federal parliamentarian.”

Dr Haines, who had both legs amputated following the attack, remains in hospital in a serious but stable condition.

Transport Minister Catherine King said while she believed the AFP looked after politicians “very well”, beefing up security arrangements at Parliament House was potentially on the agenda.

The minister also noted that the personal safety threat against MPs and senators had grown significantly worse in recent years.

“It is when, not if, that something will happen to one of us and we’ve been saying that certainly for the last five years or so,” Ms King said.

On Monday morning, One Nation MP Barnaby Joyce said political debate shouldn’t be violent, but it shouldn’t be censored either.

“Well, I don’t think people should ever be excessive,” he told Channel Seven.

“We shouldn’t need the Commissioner to tell that.”

But Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek said the attack on Dr Haines had to be a turning point for the nation.

“I think you can have strong and robust debate without being mean or cruel,” she said.

“If the Australian Federal Police and ASIO are both saying we need to change the way that we’re having political debates in this country because they are inflaming things, then I think we need to listen to that.”

Original Article published by Chris Johnson on Region Canberra.

Subscribe to PS News

Sign up now for all your free Public Sector and Defence news, delivered direct to your inbox.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Start the conversation

Be among the first to get all the Public Sector and Defence news and views that matter.

Subscribe now and receive the latest news, delivered free to your inbox.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.