27 September 2023

Holy mistaken identity! The ‘smart’ doorbell that declared war on Batman

Start the conversation

A. J. Dellinger* says a so-called smart doorbell with a built-in camera mistook a homeowner’s Batman T-shirt for an unwelcome guest and locked the door.


Usually, when Batman shows up at your front door, something has gone terribly wrong.

The Nest Hello, a smart doorbell with a built-in camera, certainly thought so when it identified the Caped Crusader approaching the front door of a man’s house last week in the US State of Georgia.

In response, the system denied access.

Just one problem: what the Nest Hello viewed as an intruder was actually just the homeowner wearing a Batman T-shirt.

B. J. May, a Javascript developer, tweeted (pictured) about getting locked out of his home when his “smart” doorbell mistook a graphic T-shirt for an unknown and unwelcome guest.

The situation came as a surprise to May, who said the system is only supposed to lock when it doesn’t recognise someone.

It should have recognised him, seeing as he’s the homeowner, but instead, the camera saw his T-shirt and focused in on the Dark Knight.

According to May, the situation was more of an hilarious misunderstanding than an actual issue; he entered his PIN on the Nest x Yale lock that is paired with the camera and was able to open the door.

He also mentioned that, in the unlikely event that he couldn’t use the PIN pad, he could also unlock the door from his phone app.

There was never a need to call a locksmith to crack open the door — though the real Batman may have been able to help out with that.

“The door will not unlock if it sees a friendly face,” May wrote.

“That’s not a feature.”

“It just reacts to an unknown face by locking the door just in case you forgot to lock it and a stranger approaches.”

“It didn’t recognise Batman.”

For owners of the Nest Hello or other Nest products wondering why their devices don’t also automatically lock their door like this, the feature isn’t provided by the device itself.

Instead, May said, he crafted a command using IFTTT, an application that allows you to link multiple devices and services to create new features based on specific prompts.

In this case, when the Nest Hello spots an unfamiliar face, it provides a notification.

When that notification is received, IFTTT tells Google Assistant, which in turn tells Nest to lock the door.

You can recreate the command on your own in IFTTT if you want, just be warned that Nest has had some technical issues with Hello in the past that caused notifications to be delayed.

* A. J. Dellinger is a tech reporter who tweets at @ajdell. His website is ajdellinger.com.

This article first appeared at www.digitaltrends.com.

Start the conversation

Be among the first to get all the Public Sector and Defence news and views that matter.

Subscribe now and receive the latest news, delivered free to your inbox.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.