
Assistant Minister Andrew Leigh has delivered a speech warning about the risks of AI increasing economic inequality if not properly utilised. Photo: Andrew Leigh.
Artificial intelligence might narrow wage gaps between employees, but widen the income divide between workers and owners of capital, if a handful of AI companies become “toll collectors” for the rest of the economy.
That’s a warning from Labor’s Assistant Minister for Productivity and Competition, Andrew Leigh, who delivered a virtual speech on Tuesday (13 October) to JPMorgan’s AI conference.
Answering the question “Will AI increase inequality?”, Dr Leigh says it has vexed economists, adding that overall income inequality could rise even as wage gaps shrink.
He shared one study that found AI boosted productivity among less-experienced customer service workers by about 30 per cent, while another study found AI eliminated three-quarters of the education-based productivity gap on a workplace-style task.
He said the biggest gains from AI may flow to those who own the technology, rather than those who use it.
“Imagine a customer support agent, two months into the job,” the Assistant Minister said.
“A small business owner appears in the chat window with a technical problem. The agent needs to diagnose what went wrong, understand the software, explain the solution clearly and deal with a customer whose patience may have already disappeared.
“In front of the agent sits an AI assistant. It has learned from millions of previous conversations, including the responses of the firm’s best workers. It suggests questions to ask and ways to explain the answer.
“Economists studied what happened when more than 5000 customer-support agents were given access to such a tool, using the staggered introduction of the technology as a natural experiment.
“Across the workforce, productivity rose by 15 per cent. Among less-skilled and less-experienced workers, the number of problems resolved per hour rose by around 30 per cent.
“With AI assistance, an agent who had been in the job for two months performed about as well as an unassisted agent with more than six months’ experience.
“Four months of experience, compressed into software.”
That study (Brynjolfsson, Li and Raymond 2025) gives a sense of why the question of how artificial intelligence affects inequality isn’t an easy one.
Dr Leigh said in the past, a solid economic rule of thumb was that new technologies tended to favour people who already had more education or expertise.
But generative AI might not work that way. It may give novices a leg up, rather than cause them to fall behind.
“Yet the distributional consequences don’t just depend on the productivity of those two workers,” he said.
“It could be that some novices earn more, but the firm hires fewer novices. It might also be the case that prices fall. And it’s possible that the owners of the AI system collect much of the gain.”
He said investors should consider not only how exposed a company is to AI, but also how its business model changes as AI becomes ubiquitous.
Firms that can use AI to scale quickly are likely to be especially attractive to investors, particularly if they can avoid a situation in which upstream providers capture much of the return.
If all banks, law firms, retailers and manufacturers relied on a small number of upstream AI systems, it would be like a toll road sitting across a growing share of the economy – with the only question being the size of the toll.
“So how can we sum up the effect of AI on inequality? I would draw two conclusions: one positive, the other a little less optimistic,” Dr Leigh said.
“First, generative AI appears capable of compressing productivity differences among workers.
“Studies repeatedly find larger productivity gains among people who begin with less experience, less education or lower measured performance.
“That distinguishes this technology from many earlier waves of computerisation.
“The second conclusion is a smidgin more challenging.
“The risk of AI on inequality is not primarily through its effect on the wage distribution.
“It lies in who gets hired, who owns the productive assets, and how much of the surplus is captured by firms with market power.
“It also lies in which countries are able to deploy AI throughout their economies while retaining a substantial share of the returns.”
Meanwhile, a parliamentary inquiry into AI, established after the recent OpenAI data breach, has recommended strengthening Australia’s copyright laws to protect authors and creatives.
The inquiry co-chair, Liberal senator Jonno Duniam, said on Tuesday that Australian content was being used to train AI models overseas, with a “whole raft of creatives” currently receiving no compensation.
“Australian copyright holders need to have control over how their material is used, and of course be compensated for that,” Senator Duniam said.
“Doing nothing is not an option; that has been made abundantly clear across all witnesses at the inquiry hearings last week.”
Original Article published by Chris Johnson on Region Canberra.
