26 September 2023

Ask the Doctor

Start the conversation

By Paul Gover.

Q: I’m keen to look at an EV as I’ve had the Lexus Hybrid CT200h for a few years, and been quite happy, however am keen to look at a fully EV.

What would your recommendations be?

I’m after a sedan that isn’t too expensive and I don’t drive much more than 200 kilometres per week.

Danielle B

A: I hope you have a big budget. Best EV choice with a Lexus already in the garage would be the new Mini E, which is fully electric, compact, but not cheap at $59,900 and you’ll need to move fast to get one. Otherwise, the Hyundai Kona electric would be runner-up.


Q: I only drive my 2002 Hyundai Accent once a fortnight to the supermarket and back, a total of 14 kilometres.

I have full tank of fuel and wonder if unleaded petrol goes off.

The next time I put petrol in the car could be 2 months or more.

Michael S

A: Yes, petrol goes ’sour’, but it takes years and not weeks or even months.


Q: My grand-daughter, who lives with us (17 years going 30), wishes to purchase a Renault Megane 2001 convertible.

She’s a learner driver, the car has 190,000 on the clock and appears in good condition, with everything working for $3800.00.

What is your opinion? What should I look out for.? Are they expensive to service/repair?

As it will be her first car, is it safe ?

Mick L

A: Really? She loves the look, I’m sure. But as a parent there are far smarter and safer choices. And they are not cheap to fix. Please remember to get her a safe driving course with a company like Murcotts in Melbourne.


Q: What would you suggest as a good secondhand delivery vehicle to buy and use to drive for a company like Toll?

It would be for use around town.

Mark D

A: I would go for a Hyundai iLoad. Not as well known as similar Toyota models, but solid and good value, also probably with some factory warranty if you buy one less than five years old.


Q: My wife is currently driving a 2014 Nissan Pathfinder but the kids are getting older and we no longer require such a big car.

She likes the height of an SUV, but would like to downsize.

She’s looking for something not that old but around the $25,000 mark secondhand, but still a mid-sized SUV.

What would you suggest?

Daryl D

A: With that budget, I’d go for a near-new Kia Sportage. But … you could also probably look at a new Hyundai Kona. Both are good cars and great value.


Q: I currently have a Mazda CX-9 which had done 315,000 kilometres.

I really enjoy driving it and feel extremely comfortable with the seats. The only issue is the fuel economy.

I am looking at updating and wanted your opinion of the CX-8 diesel, as I drive around 45,000 kilometres a year, on freeway and around Melbourne metro area.

I understand the CX-8 is slightly smaller than CX-9, however the interior size is fine.

What do you think of the CX8 diesel? Any other vehicles you would consider in this size range?

Trevor H

A: Honestly, diesel makes almost no sense today except for heavyweight towing. Fuel is not that cheap, a small-capacity turbo petrol engine will deliver economy that’s close to diesel, and the engine is more expensive at the start. That said, there are plenty of family-sized SUVs now. The latest CX-9 is still good with petrol and of the newer models, the VW Tiguan is a ripper.

If you have a question for the Car Doctor, send an email to [email protected]

Start the conversation

Be among the first to get all the Public Sector and Defence news and views that matter.

Subscribe now and receive the latest news, delivered free to your inbox.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.